BACK TO REALITY

On, Federer’s shoe in Court for false environmental claims

La denuncia è partita dalla Federazione romanda dei consumatori. Al centro della disputa, la scarpa Cloudneo, prodotta dal marchio svizzero legato all'ex numero 1 del tennis e presentata come 100% riciclabile
Swiss brand On's shoe model accused of unfair competition for its false environmental claims.
Swiss brand On's shoe model accused of unfair competition for its false environmental claims.

They were presented as “the first step in our journey towards circularity”. Through the shoes of the Cloudneo line (and another series of sportswear) the Swiss brand On, famous for counting among its members the former world number 1 tennis player Roger Federer, promises to bring the world of fashion applied to sport into the world of the circular economy. In fact, it has launched the Cyclon™ program that allows, upon payment of a monthly subscription, to “rent” your own running shoes, among other things made of bio-based materials, and send them back to the parent company every 6 months, to have them replaced and at the same time have the guarantee that the old pair would have been 100% recycled.

The FRC’s accusation

It’s all too good to be true, according to the Federation of Romande Consumers (FRC), which in fact announced in recent days that it has started legal action against the Hon. The accusation: unfair competition for violation of Swiss law which, since last January, has banned advertisements “relating to climate impact that cannot be demonstrated on objective and verifiable grounds”. Something similar to what is provided for in the European directive on green claims that will come into force next year.

https://thewashingnews.com/en/green-claims-directive-ue/

The investigation by the broadcaster RTS

The complaint by the consumer association FRC was triggered by a journalistic investigation published last June by the program Temps Présent of RTS – Radio Télévisione Suisse and taken up in Italian by the program Falò of the Rete Svizzera Italiana: in its report, the newspaper reconstructed the recycling chain promised by On but, according to what was reconstructed by the Swiss journalists, never activated: almost two years after the launch, in fact, the company had not recycled any shoes, despite the fact that in the meantime tens of thousands of pieces had been collected and sent back to the sender by consumers who had signed up for the “loyalty program” proposed by the company.

FRC, moreover, arrived at the complaint only after having attempted to take a more conciliatory path with On. Discussions that, according to the association cited by RTS, “only led to small changes to the brand’s website”.

The Swiss public broadcaster also questioned On at the end of 2024. On that occasion, a company spokesperson said that they had started an initial recycling of 1,000 shoes in August 2023 and promised to recycle all returned shoes.

“Consumers, report it”

On is probably not an isolated case. For the FRC, in fact, many companies voluntarily spread vague and meaningless statements that end up misleading consumers by convincing them of environmental concerns that are actually pure marketing. For this reason, the Swiss association has invited citizens to report cases of suspected greenwashing, present in advertising or other corporate communications.

Actions in Parliament

The general secretary of FRC, Sophie Michaud Gigon, who is also a national councilor for the Greens in Vaud, denounced that the current law is not stringent enough to prevent unfair practices by companies. In particular, the definition of what is actually sustainable and ecological is not sufficiently detailed. A gap exploited by companies to spread misleading information to consumers.

In this regard, the parliamentarian has presented a series of motions to the Swiss National Council to improve the fight against greenwashing: among her requests is that of increasing the powers of the State Secretariat for Economic Affairs and the amount of fines.